There's a general rule-of-thumb that if you are trying to get people to believe some outlandish idea, you do not increase your chances of success by altering it to make it even more outlandish. If, for example, your particular shtick is that the Earth is a flat disk, you will not sound more plausible by adding that it was put in motion by the god Frisbeus, and during the End Times the Devil will alter its orbit so it gets stuck up on the Celestial Roof.
This goes double if you give your idea a silly name. Frisbeeterianism, for example.
This is a rule-of-thumb that the UFO/UAP crowd seem not to have taken to heart, given an article I've now been sent three times by well-meaning loyal readers of Skeptophilia, to the effect that the rumor now circulating amongst "whistleblowers" is that the aliens are using the Earth as a "misery farm," getting things set up so as to generate maximum despair, because they feed off negative emotional energy.
Called "loosh."
Apparently loosh has been around for a while, originating in 1985 with a dude named Robert Monroe who was seriously into out-of-body experiences. Monroe, however, envisioned loosh as nice stuff; the "essence of universal love." This kind of energy (using the latter term in its non-scientific sense), Monroe said, is nourishing to the soul, and therefore our benevolent alien overlords want us to produce as much as possible, then share the stuff around.
It bears keeping in mind, however, that Monroe also wrote a book about visiting "The Park," which is the Reception Center for heaven, where spirits go immediately after death to recuperate for a while. How Monroe got there without dying first is an open question, so we're kind of in deep water right off the bat.
In any case, loosh got picked up by conspiracy theorist David Icke, and that's where things took a darker turn. Because, after all, you can't have a good conspiracy theory based on a plot to make everyone really nice to each other, whether aliens are involved or not. Icke claimed that Monroe had misinterpreted loosh; it's not the essence of love, it's actually a negative spiritual energy generated when people are miserable. In Icke's view, the Earth is a prison planet, and our alien masters want us to be upset, because then they have more food to eat, or something.
I have to admit that as a model, this works surprisingly well. The last ten years have been not only a non-stop shitshow, but off-the-register weird. It would explain a lot if there are superpowerful aliens who are just fucking with us. I mean, the other option is that Donald Trump and the MAGA movement are some kind of naturally-occurring phenomenon, and I don't know about you, but for me that stretches credibility to the snapping point.
But one thing I'll give the alien overlords: if there really is a plot to make every smart person on Earth extremely depressed, so far it's working brilliantly.
In any case, apparently there are now UFO Truthers out there who not only want the government to 'fess up about alien spacecraft sightings, but also to admit that the government is in league with the aliens to keep us all trapped in the Slough of Despond. In some versions, the elected officials themselves are alien shapeshifters (in the case of Stephen Miller, the shape honestly hasn't shifted much). In other versions, they're just collaborators who are hoping the aliens will keep them in power so the feast can continue.
What's vaguely unsettling about all this -- I mean, besides the fact that there are people who take it seriously -- is that this is strangely close to the plot of my novel, Eyes Like Midnight.
It is a work of fiction.
Like, I made the story up from beginning to end. It's based on an urban legend that's been around for a while, but that, too, is fiction.
Given all that, I'm inclined to think that "Earth as misery-producing prison planet" is as well.
Or, who knows? Maybe I'm one of the collaborators myself, and by writing this I'm just trying to sow doubt in your mind. Maybe the whole fifteen-year history of this blog has, all along, been one elaborate exercise in misdirection. Each time I post here, I cackle maniacally and wiggle my fingertips in a menacing fashion, just delighted at how many people I'm bamboozling with all this nonsense about "science" and "skepticism" and "rationality."
When the reality is that the Earth is actually shaped like a donut. With sprinkles.
Now, y'all'll have to excuse me, because I think I need to go lie down for a while. You can only exude so much loosh before you start feeling a little light-headed.

I don't think that you should be surprised. I'm sure that you know that the value of a shibboleth as a marker of tribal loyalty increases the more that it deviates from common sense. That is why North Korean and Trumpian acolytes compete with each other in fulsomeness. See also the rationale for competitive loyalty oaths in Catch22.
ReplyDelete