There are at least two differences between me and your typical woo-woo.
One is that I at least try to apply the principles of scientific induction to what I see around me. Insofar as I'm able, given the limitations I have as a non-specialist, I base what I believe, say, and do on evidence and logic.
The second is that when I do say something egregiously wrong, I apologize and back down.
As far as the second goes, there seems to be an unwritten rule in all different disciplines of woo-woodom that goes something like "death before recision." Even confronted by incontrovertible evidence that they're in error -- or worse, that they've cheated and lied -- they never change their stance. The most they do -- such as the hilarious snafu "Psychic Sally Morgan" got herself into when she used her mediumistic skills to get in contact with the spirit of someone who turned out to be fictional -- is to remain silent for a while and hope everyone forgets what happened.
But before long, they're back at it, undaunted, and once again raking in accolades and money from the gullible.
No one is a better example of this than the redoubtable Uri Geller. Geller, you probably know, is the Israeli "psychic and telekinetic" who claimed to be able not only to "see with his mind," but to manipulate objects remotely. Geller has been called a fraud by many, most notably James Randi, whose book The Truth about Uri Geller resulted in a fifteen million dollar lawsuit against Randi and his publisher.
Geller lost.
But nothing was quite as humiliating as his 1973 appearance on The Tonight Show, where he was asked to demonstrate his most common claim, which was that he could bend spoons with his mind. The problem is, Carson himself was a trained stage magician, so he -- literally -- knew all the tricks. He suspected that Geller was pre-preparing his props (specifically, bending the spoons repeatedly ahead of time so they had a weak point), and refused to let Geller handle them before the show. As a result, Geller couldn't do... well, anything. Even if I'm completely on Carson's side, watching the sequence is profoundly cringe-inducing.
Which is mighty convenient.
What's most remarkable is that after this, Geller didn't do what I'd have done, which is to join a Trappist monastery and spend the rest of my life in total silence. After a (brief) period to regain his footing, he just went right on claiming he could perform telekinesis...
... and people kept right on believing him.
What is truly extraordinary, though, is that over fifty years later, he's still at it. An article in The Jerusalem Post two days ago describes his claim that Greta Thunberg's ship Madleen, which is on the way to Gaza to provide relief for the embattled region, had mechanical problems because he remotely damaged their equipment.
"I stopped the navigation systems of the ship," Geller said. "I will use my psychic powers to stop [her] ship... Remote viewing is sending your mind through space and time. If I attach my psychokinetic energy through remote viewing, I can locate exactly where the navigational instruments are on her boat... It's like a laser, like the IDF's new weapon, the Iron Beam. That's how powerful the mind is for some people... I can navigate my mind into whatever I want to."
Johnnie Carson also thwarted another Geller trick: finding which small container contains a load, by serruptitiously bumping the table to see which one doesn't shake. Carson brought out a table that had the containers glued down.
ReplyDelete