Birds of a feather

The diversity you find among birds is really remarkable.

There are differences in bill shape, from the weird angled beaks of flamingos, to the longer-on-the-bottom fish skewers of skimmers, to the upswept needle of the avocet, to the absurd (and aptly-named) spoonbills and shoebills, to the pelicans -- about whom my dad taught me a limerick when I was little:

A wonderful bird is the pelican.
His bill can hold more than his bellican.
He can stash in his beak
All his food for the week,
But I really don't see how the hellican.

Yeah, it's kind of obvious where I got my sense of humor from.

Of course, it doesn't end there. The impossibly long toes of the South American jacanas (called "lilytrotters" because they can walk on the floating leaves of waterlilies).  The phenomenal wingspan of the albatross.  The insane plumage of the birds-of-paradise.

And the colors.  Man, the colors!  Even in my decidedly non-tropical home we have some pretty amazing birds.  The first time I saw an Indigo Bunting, I was certain that one of my sons had put a blue plastic bird on the bird feeder just to rattle my chain.  There couldn't be a real bird that was that fluorescent shade of cobalt.

Then... it moved.

But nothing prepared me for the colors I saw on my visits to Ecuador, especially amongst the birds of the tanager family.  There are hundreds of species of tanagers in that tiny little country, and because they often travel in mixed foraging flocks, you can sometimes see twenty or thirty different species in the same tree.  These include the Green-headed Tanager:

[Image licensed under the Creative Commons Lars Falkdalen Lindahl (User:Njaelkies Lea), Green-headed Tanager Ubatuba, CC BY-SA 3.0]

The Black-capped Tanager:

[Image licensed under the Creative Commons Joseph C Boone, Black-capped Tanager JCB, CC BY-SA 4.0]

And the Flame-faced Tanager:

[Image licensed under the Creative Commons Eleanor Briccetti, Flame-faced Tanager (4851596008), CC BY-SA 2.0]

Being a biologist, of course the question of how these birds evolved such extravagant colors is bound to come up, and my assumption was always that it was sexual selection -- the females choosing the most brightly-colored males as mates (in this group, as with many bird species, the males are usually vividly decked out and the females are drab-colored). If over time, the showiest males are the most likely to get lucky, then you get sexual dimorphism -- the evolution of different outward appearances between males and females.  (This isn't always so, by the way.  Most species of sparrows, for example, have little sexual dimorphism, and even experienced birders can't tell a male from a female sparrow by looking.)  More puzzling still is the general trend that tropical birds are more brilliantly-colored than bird species in higher latitudes -- a trend that is yet to be convincingly explained.

The reason this comes up today is two papers that came out last week.  The first, that appeared in Science Advances, looks at one of the most amazing things about their evolutionary history -- they were the only branch of the dinosaur clade that survived the cataclysmic mass extinction at the end of the Cretaceous Period.  What allowed birds to make it through the bottleneck that killed all of their near relatives -- and not only survive, but thrive and rediversify?

The evidence is that the extinction event selected for two things; small body size, and a shift toward young being altricial -- born relatively helpless and undeveloped, and therefore requiring more parental care.  Some lineages of birds would eventually increase in body size again, but they never again would reach the colossal proportions that their cousins did during the Jurassic and Cretaceous Periods.

"We have typically not looked at the change in DNA composition and model across the tree of life as a change that something interesting has happened at a particular point of time and place," said Stephen Smith, of the University of Michigan, who co-authored the study.  "This study illustrates that we have probably been missing something...  We found that adult body size and patterns of pre-hatching development are two important features of bird biology we can link to the genetic changes we’re detecting.  One of the most significant challenges in evolutionary biology and ornithology is teasing out the relationships between major bird groups — it’s difficult to determine the structure of the tree of life for living birds."

The study not only elucidated relationships between extant groups of birds, it allowed the researchers to pinpoint when groups diverged from each other, and therefore what innovations were likely to be connected with events occurring on the Earth at the time.

The second study, which appeared in Nature Ecology & Evolution, looked at the question I began with -- the impossibly bright colors that are characteristic of so many bird species.  Colors in birds arise two ways -- pigments (chemicals which absorb some frequencies of light and reflect others) and structural color (due to feathers creating a combination of refraction and interference; this is also known as iridescence).  Most pigmented color in birds is relatively drab -- blacks, grays, and various shades of brown -- the flashing blues, greens, and purples you see in groups like tanagers, hummingbirds, and sunbirds are almost entirely due to iridescence.

The researchers went through images of as many of the 9,409 species of birds currently in existence, along with the current best iteration of the family tree of birds, to try and figure out where along the way iridescence evolved, and how it spread so widely among this class of animals.  

And what they found was that 415 distantly-related branches of the tree have iridescent feathers, and the common ancestor of all modern birds -- something like eighty million years ago -- was very likely iridescent.

"I was very excited to learn that the ancestral state of all birds is iridescence," said Chad Eliason, of the Field Museum in Chicago, who was the paper's lead author.  "We've found fossil evidence of iridescent birds and other feathered dinosaurs before, by examining fossil feathers and the preserved pigment-producing structures in those feathers.  So we know that iridescent feathers existed back in the Cretaceous -- those fossils help support the idea from our model that the ancestor of all modern birds was iridescent too."

There are still a lot of questions left unanswered, however.  "We still don't know why iridescence evolved in the first place," Eliason said.  "Iridescent feathers can be used by birds to attract mates, but iridescence is related to other aspects of birds' lives too.  For instance, tree swallows change color when the humidity changes, so iridescence could be related to the environment, or it might be related to another physical property of feathers, like water resistance.  But knowing more about how there came to be so many iridescent birds in the tropics might help us understand why iridescence evolved."

Which is extremely cool.  Something to think about next time you see one of those brilliant little flying jewels flit by.  The stunning colors we appreciate every day on our bird feeders and in the wild have a very long history -- going back to a trait that evolved something like eighty million years ago.

****************************************